"Tall people are taller than short people, which make short people uncomfortable. Therefore there's not such thing as being tall."
This kind of thinking, which is getting more common every day, make us smile when it's done by children. When it's adults however, it's absolutely terrifying to me.
That's not the point of what I said... I acknowledge that some kids end up smarter than others. I just don't put most of that difference down to innate intelligence. I'm not even sure there is such a thing. I highly doubt the difference between a 9th grader studying calc and a 9th grader studying algebra is some great brain difference. They're both straightforwards subjects that anyone can learn.
We're not talking about asking TAG students to develop a new version of string theory. We're asking them to ingest already discovered information and apply it. The idea that this requires innate intelligence is just silly. Anyone can be trained to do these things. Those who work harder will be able to get into these courses.
What I find dangerous is the attribution of all material differences between people to genetics/predisposition. This thinking leads to the end of meritocracy, and even the celebration of achievement.
This kind of thinking, which is getting more common every day, make us smile when it's done by children. When it's adults however, it's absolutely terrifying to me.