Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can someone explain the uptown / downtown train story to me?

If the downtown train arrives and departs a few minutes after the uptown train arrives and departs, respectively, why would he take the downtown train more? It seems to me that if he missed both trains, then he would take the uptown train, as it would arrive earlier.



He is saying the opposite. The downtown train arrives on the hour and the uptown train arrives at 5 minutes after the hour.


The description has it the other way.

"The solution is that, even though the trains arrive with the same frequency, the downtown train departs just a few minutes after the uptown train has departed. Because of this, there is only a narrow time window in which the man is able to get on the uptown train."

s/after/before/ to fix the explanation.


No, he does not say the opposite:

>even though the trains arrive with the same frequency, the downtown train departs just a few minutes after the uptown train has departed. Because of this, there is only a narrow time window in which the man is able to get on the uptown train.

He should say it like you suggested though.


You're right. I was looking at the diagram. Clearly the author accidentally swapped the two names in that sentence.


You are correct, he messed up telling the story.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: